View Single Post
Old 23-05-2005   #21 (permalink)
sTisTi
CD Freaks Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 129
Re: MP3 VBR or CBR at What Rate??

Quote:
Originally Posted by Parato Optimal
How much smaller are flac files compared to wavs?
Monkey's Audio form saves me about 50% over wav format.


When I was setting 128/320 min/max for variable rips I'd get say a 181-bitrate.
The same song ripped at 192/320 min/max would deliver @ 221-bitrate.
In light of the first rip, shouldn't the second rip have been as low as it could've gone which would have been 192-bitrate?
FLACs are usually slightly larger than Monkey's Audio files => worse compression ratio, but faster encoding/decoding
As for the 192 minimum bitrate, your 181-bitrate file certainly has some frames of 224, 256 and even 320. If you set the minimum bitrate to 192, the higher kbps frames will remain as in your 128-minimum file, so the average bitrate will always be higher than 192, unless all frames use 192 or less also when using 128 as minimum bitrate.
sTisTi is offline   Reply With Quote