That guy that did those still-capture comparisons is a newbie with 4 posts. Why should anyone take his word? It is funny how everyone follows someone else's opinion rather than just download the program out and try it free for 30 days themselves!
I have tried
CloneDVD and find the quality is as good or better than
DVD2One. The program itself is real slick. Too many people criticize the fact about the sheep eating popcorn but that is nitpicking and nothing to do with the ease-of-use and the good results one gets.
I think there were debates reacently comparing other transcoders with still captures and, after a bit of arguing, people came to the conclusion that still shots do not give a definitive test for the quality of a motion video. I don't see why people start this crap all over again.